Real-World Example
ABC Collections sends Jane a settlement offer for $800 on a $1,000 balance. The offer was generated from the group-level payment terms that applied when the creditor sent the offer. Jane responds with a $600 settlement counteroffer. Before the counteroffer is routed to ABC Collections, the system should validate Jane’s counteroffer against the group-level terms that were actually delivered to her. When Jane sends a counteroffer for creditor review, it appears in Open Negotiations and the sidebar badge updates. If she accepts an instant offer or her own proposal qualifies for automatic approval, she continues to payment setup.Visual Flow
Purpose
Open Negotiations manages settlement and payment-plan offers that require manual creditor action after system validation. This section applies to:- Consumer counteroffers to creditor-initiated digital offers.
- Settlement or payment-plan offers converted from a Notice Response after the creditor adds the account and the offer does not qualify for automatic approval.
- Notice Response intake, routing, or account creation.
- Written-notice dispute or no-pay intake.
- Consumer offers before the creditor has validated and added the account.
Workflow Overview
Creditor Sends Offer
The creditor sends a settlement offer or payment plan offer. The delivered offer may be based on:- Master payment terms.
- Sub-account payment terms.
- Group payment terms.
Consumer Submits Counteroffer
The consumer may submit a settlement counteroffer or payment plan counteroffer. Example:- Balance: $1,000.
- Creditor offer: $800.
- Consumer counteroffer: $600.
Notice Response Exception
When a creditor selects Add Account for a Notice Response, settlement and payment-plan offers are evaluated against the creditor’s Master Pay Terms. Qualifying offers are handled automatically. Offers that do not qualify become active Open Negotiations items after the account is created.How Counteroffers Reach Open Negotiations
Master, Sub-Account, and Group Offers evaluate the proposal using the terms delivered for that account. The portal approves qualifying proposals immediately. When a proposal is eligible for review, the consumer can accept the instant alternative or send their original proposal. When it falls outside the review limits, the consumer can accept the instant alternative or submit the eligible counteroffer shown. Only a proposal explicitly submitted for review appears in Open Negotiations. The item shows the terms the consumer chose to send. A changed proposal on an Individual Offer goes directly to creditor review. The creditor can still accept, decline, or counter an item in review.Creditor Actions
- Accept.
- Decline.
- Counter.
Action Flows
Accept Flow
If a payment method exists:- Settlement processes automatically, or the payment plan activates.
- Negotiation is marked resolved.
- Open count decreases.
- Consumer is notified.
- Status becomes
Needs Payment Method. - Consumer must add a payment method before expiration.
- Negotiation remains pending until resolved or expired.
Decline Flow
- Consumer is notified.
- Negotiation is marked declined.
- Open count decreases.
Counteroffer Flow
- Consumer receives the creditor counteroffer.
- Negotiation remains active.
- Badge remains active.
Creditor Review Flow
Visibility And Badge Rules
- Creditors only see their own negotiations.
- Resolved negotiations are hidden from Open Negotiations.
- Expired negotiations are hidden from Open Negotiations.
- History must be preserved.
Status Definitions
How It Should Work
- Only validated digital counteroffers and added Notice Response offers requiring creditor action should appear here.
- Counteroffer validation should occur before routing to Open Negotiations.
- Automatically approved offers and proposals awaiting a consumer choice stay outside the queue.
- Badge counts should reflect real unread or unresolved activity.
- Accepted offers should trigger the correct settlement or payment plan execution flow.
- Missing payment methods should create a
Needs Payment Methodstate. - Completed, resolved, declined, or expired negotiations should be removed from Open Negotiations while preserving history.
How It Should Not Work
- It should not show unprocessed Notice Response intake, written-notice disputes, or no-pay intake in this queue.
- It should not show negotiations from another creditor.
- It should not allow term editing in Open Negotiations.
- It should not leave stale badge counts after activity is handled.
- It should not route invalid offers to manual review.
- It should not create duplicate negotiation threads for the same active offer.
Architecture Recommendation
Each negotiation should be represented as a persistent thread tied to:- Consumer.
- Creditor.
- Account.
- Original offer.
- All offers and counteroffers.
- Status history.
- Read and unread state.
- Expiration.
- Resolution.
- Payment method state.

